Hidden Sister: The Gospel of Luke is the only one that recounts Jesus’ healing of a woman who had been bent over for eighteen years (Luke 13:10-17). This passage is assigned to Monday of the Thirtieth Week in Ordinary Time. Although Jesus recognizes her as a “daughter of Abraham,” this story of her faith and Jesus’ willingness to break the Sabbath law in the synagogue and heal her is not proclaimed on any Sunday. Moreover, in 2024, this reading is replaced by the proper readings for the Feast of Saints Simon and Jude. More Hidden Sisters.
Christine
Christine
Schenk, C.S.J.
Schenk, C.S.J.
She at once stood up straight and glorified God
Being a woman of a certain age, I can easily identify with the bent over woman in today’s Gospel. Doctors tell us that after age 40, people typically lose almost one half inch of height every ten years, owing to the decrease of spinal cartilage that occurs with normal aging. After a bone density test my doctor told me I had the best bones he had seen all year. Thanks to my Irish heritage, I probably won’t be physically bent over any time soon.
But it is hard to watch lifelong friends become increasingly frail as their heads and torsos slowly begin to curve and tilt downward. The bent over woman in today’s Gospel probably suffered from osteoporosis, which could easily occur with the poor diet that was all too common among oppressed Israelites, especially among women who fed their children first.
Yet here she is, painfully shuffling into the synagogue to honor her God on the sabbath day.
And here is a compassionate Jesus, watching as she stumbles along. Moved by her sad state, he tells her: “Woman, you are set free of your infirmity” and lays his hands on her. Immediately she stands up straight and glorifies God. I’m guessing the woman could hardly take in what had just happened. After all, she hadn’t even asked Jesus for a healing. He just knew what she needed and released her from long years of suffering.
Unfortunately the hall monitors of the universe at the synagogue couldn’t let this go on. They issue this order to the woman and the crowd: “There are six days when work should be done. Come on those days to be cured, not on the sabbath day.”
Seriously? Were they afraid that teeming hordes of the afflicted might come to God for healing on the sabbath? Why would that not be a good thing? Why not rejoice in the healing power of God, that on this day had freed their sister from a terrible affliction?
Reflecting on this text, I realize that even though my own body is not bent over, my spirit very often is. I too am the bent over woman, too often weighed down with my carefully constructed to-do list, and myriad other obligations some of which aren’t even mine, (my default being a rather compulsive hyper responsibility.)
One trouble with being bent over—whether physically or spiritually—is that one’s vision is seriously confined to a very small expanse. Jesus’s spontaneous desire to heal allows the woman in the Gospel—and me on my good days—to stand upright and take in the larger horizon which includes a healing God who is not bound by narrow ideas concerning the appropriate time for healing—(or the appropriate timeline for my task list.)
Now is the time for healing, says Jesus. Now, today, on this sabbath day, is the time to celebrate and praise the abundant love and vision of our healing mother- father God.
Jesus decries the rigidity of the rule keepers—a perennial affliction of religious leaders of every denomination even to our own day— "Don’t you understand? Freeing this woman, this daughter of Abraham is more important than freeing the ox and ass as your religious rules allow?” The phrase “Daughter of Abraham” occurs nowhere else in either the Hebrew or Christian scriptures. Jesus is saying “ This woman is a fully equal member of God’s own people, and her dignity and well-being must be the priority here.”
A recent meme circulating of Facebook says it all: “Religious people will destroy a person to keep a tradition, but Jesus will break a tradition to help a person.” Traditions are important. But they are not the most important consideration when it comes to people who are hurting. For Jesus, healing the hurt is the most important consideration.
I think Jesus asks religious people – who, perhaps like me, also suffer from being spiritually bent over - to expand our horizons; put wounded, hurting people first, and leave our valued traditions and necessary rules in their proper, secondary place. We cannot create rigid boundaries that miss the point by excluding people from God’s expansive, overarching love.
So today, let each of us also stumble into the presence of Jesus. Let us bring our own bent over brokenness to his healing horizon which is broader than any we can imagine.
And then we too can rejoice and stand upright in praise of an amazing God whose love can never be confined.
Christine Schenk, CSJ
Christine Schenk, CSJ
Christine Schenk, CSJ has worked as a nurse midwife to low-income families, a community organizer, an award-winning writer-researcher, and the founding director of an international church reform organization, FutureChurch. Her first book Crispina and Her Sisters: Women and Authority in Early Christianity (Fortress Press, 2017) received a first place in history from the Catholic Press Association and her most recent work, To Speak the Truth in Love: A Biography of Sr. Theresa Kane RSM (Orbis Books 2019) received first place awards from The Association of Catholic Publishers and the Catholic Press Association.
Her forthcoming book Bending Toward Justice: Sister Kate Kuenstler and the Struggle for Parish Rights tells the story of the rampant closings of vibrant Catholic parishes across the United States and documents the courageous advocacy of Sr. Kate and hundreds—indeed thousands—of ordinary Catholics whose persistence charted a new course in canon law. It will be published by Rowman Littlefield on December 17, 2024.
Schenk also writes a regular column for the National Catholic Reporter and is one of three nuns featured in the award-winning documentary Radical Grace. Schenk graduated Magna Cum Laude from Georgetown University and holds two masters’ degrees, one in science from Boston College and an MA in Theology "with distinction" from St. Mary Seminary and Graduate School of Theology in Cleveland.
October 17 at 7pm ET: Join Catholic Women Preach, FutureChurch, contributors to the Year C book, and co-editors Elizabeth Donnelly and Russ Petrus as we celebrate the release of the third and final volume of this ground-breaking, award winning series.
"Catholic Women Preach is one of the more inspiring collection of homilies available today. Based on the deep spirituality and insights of the various women authors, the homilies are solidly based on the scriptures and offer refreshing and engaging insights for homilists and listeners. The feminine perspective has long been absent in the preached word, and its inclusion in this work offers a long overdue and pastorally necessary resource for the liturgical life of the Church." - Catholic Media Association
Advertise with Catholic Women Preach: email Russ at russ@futurechurch.org